Georgetown, Cayman Islands
The catamaran was beautiful and spacious enough that everyone on board could have a little bit to themselves. The crew was friendly and service was exceptional. They put the sails up and moved the boat around to offer all sorts of excellent photo ops. The food was just okay, but the experience completely eclipsed that. Well worth it.
My only complaint - when my husband and I (who couldn't take the shuttle because we were out at Morritt's) arrived, we were given conflicting directions from everyone and it was really stressful trying to figure out what to do and where to go right up to the time we were boarding. Just know that the boat pulls up right on the beach at the Beach Suites, no dock necessary! When they say wait out front, wait out back.